Some of the press reports about the House of Bishops action on Resolution D025 have been incomplete or, in some cases, completely misleading. Accurate coverage can be found here. And since I voted in the affirmative, and with the majority, I also offer these reflections of my own for your consideration.
First, the resolution deserves a reading in its totality, despite a tendency to separate the most newsworthy section from the rest and treat it in isolation. Five of the seven resolves in this action, for example, directly address the participation of the Episcopal Church in the Anglican Communion. While this resolution addresses the rightful place of gay men and lesbians in the common life of the Episcopal Church, that life is given context within a community of Christians larger than this Church alone. D025 addresses both inclusion and communion—and gives greater attention to issues of communion.
Second, the resolution recognizes the canonical access to the ordination process for gay men and lesbians, a recognition which they and their allies have asked for, and for which they and I are grateful. They also understand fully, I believe, that access to a process is never a guarantee of ordination itself. Our canonical and pastoral processes toward ordination never treat ordination as a right for anyone. But anyone has the full privilege of presenting himself or herself to the Church in order to say: I believe I am so called. This is a pastoral clarification which D025 makes, for the sake of gay men and lesbians.
Third, and with this being the case, D025 does not in itself represent an end to the moratorium on the ordination of partnered gay men or lesbians to the episcopate. To state the obvious, this moratorium would end only in the event of such an ordination.
Fourth, the resolution explicitly notes and affirms that the Church, both in this province and in the worldwide communion, is not of one mind on these matters.
This resolution has been appreciatively received by the gay men and lesbians within our Church, and I rejoice with them for this clarification which the General Convention has been working to offer. I ask, with them, for a full and careful reading of the entire resolution.
The Rt. Rev. George Wayne Smith
Tenth Bishop of Missouri
